How children entering without legal permission should be treated

This morning I received an e-mail from the Los Angeles County Department of Children and Family Services (DCFS) soliciting providers of residential services to consider offering much needed services to the growing numbers of children overwhelming the United States southern borders. These children are seeking refuge from violence in their native Central American countries. Since Hillsides’ residential services have such a high utilization level, we do not have the capacity to serve these children. The child welfare system, in general, is ill-prepared for such a large influx of what some are calling “refugees.” However, as an organization committed to serving children who are at-risk of violence, seeing this humanitarian crisis unfold without advocating for these vulnerable children is hard.

There are, of course, political forces at play that use this situation to make a statement about immigration reform. The voices on either side are loud, provocative, and intended to polarize. In the midst of the shouting matches and the intimidating confrontations are the children. These children, who flee the violence and instability of their home country, find themselves the victims of the intransient forces that have brought the political process in our country to a grinding halt.

The current system, though painstakingly slow, will return these children back to their counties of origin. What refuge they sought will be denied in favor of the principles of law and order. The dangers they encountered on their perilous journey were for naught. The hopes they had for a life free from violence, intimidation, and poverty will be deferred if not dashed to pieces.

As all this unfolds so close to our Independence Day celebrations, I cannot help but feel sad for these poor children and also for our country as we are unable to honor the valiant efforts of these desperate children and youth to be free of violence.

If we cannot be a refuge, then the least we can do is treat these refugees with dignity and respect. Although, as an organization we do not have the capacity to serve these children, I am heartened by the call from DCFS as an agent for the Federal government to find some way to accommodate these children while they are here before being returned.

Given the challenges we face to address the children already in our care, it is hard to imagine how the child welfare system will effectively attend to such an influx of children in need. There is no question that our resources are limited and strained as it is. However, the nightmare that these children entering without legal permission have experienced is traumatizing. If nothing else, they deserve to be treated with the respect and dignity afforded all children, including those who are vulnerable.

Although there may be little we can do, we certainly can remind the loud voices on either side that their political positions do not excuse them or any of us from ignoring the plight of these children and providing for them as best we can while they are among us.

Image source: Murrieta protest over immigrant kids exposes political divisions article published on http://www.sfgate.com/news/article/Immigrant-kids-Murrieta-protest-stoke-political-5599341.php; Photo: Gregory Bull, Associated Press

2 Comments on “How children entering without legal permission should be treated

  1. Thank you, Joe, for speaking out on this matter and giving a voice to those of us who are appalled by the events of recent days. Finding a humane solution must be part of the choice made for the treatment of these innocents. Where are our religious leaders and churches? Their voices are not coming to the forefront here. Ida Hitchcock

  2. I am a 21 year police veteran and current police detective that has actively investigated hundreds of child abuse cases. I am also a victim of DCFS corruption. I offer the following advice: Do not ever speak to DCFS…When they come to your home, step outside and close the door behind you…Collect their business card and listen to the allegation against you…Then exert your right to reman silent and do so…Do not answer ANY questions. Do not allow them into your home. Do not allow them to see or interview your children. Do not sign anything. Do not provide them with ANY information about your children or family. If you have time, record the at the door encounter. If your children are old enough, teach them how to exercise their right to remain silent; children should exercise their right to remain silent if interviewed at school or if DCFS comes back to your home with an investigative warrant (school interviews can be avoided by home schooling your children). Any investigative warrant obtained solely on an uncorroborated anonymous allegation to the DCFS hotline is illegal; you should seek an attorney to file a federal civil rights violation lawsuit under 42 USC 1983 if DCFS serves an illegal warrant on your home.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Hillsides Community Blog

CREATING LASTING CHANGE

The Daily Post

The Art and Craft of Blogging

The WordPress.com Blog

The latest news on WordPress.com and the WordPress community.

%d bloggers like this: